Comments on: Are the rituals performed for Hajj/Umrah the same for both Shia’s and Sunni’s? http://blog.hajjumrahreview.com/performing-umrah/are-the-rituals-performed-for-hajjumrah-the-same-for-both-shias-and-sunnis Take the Journey of a lifetime Wed, 23 May 2012 04:37:17 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.7 hourly 1 By: The White Horse http://blog.hajjumrahreview.com/performing-umrah/are-the-rituals-performed-for-hajjumrah-the-same-for-both-shias-and-sunnis/comment-page-1#comment-13363 The White Horse Sat, 27 Mar 2010 01:08:59 +0000 http://blog.hajjumrahreview.com/performing-umrah/are-the-rituals-performed-for-hajjumrah-the-same-for-both-shias-and-sunnis#comment-13363 my first steps in slam http://www.1ststepsinislam.com/en/<br><b>References : </b><br> my first steps in slam

http://www.1ststepsinislam.com/en/
References :

]]> By: dawuud http://blog.hajjumrahreview.com/performing-umrah/are-the-rituals-performed-for-hajjumrah-the-same-for-both-shias-and-sunnis/comment-page-1#comment-13362 dawuud Sat, 27 Mar 2010 00:54:59 +0000 http://blog.hajjumrahreview.com/performing-umrah/are-the-rituals-performed-for-hajjumrah-the-same-for-both-shias-and-sunnis#comment-13362 Yes. The division however is just political and cultural, and not religious. There were no such divisions in the time of the prophet. Its only after the time of the prophet, started over the issue, who should rightfully be the leaders over the Muslims. While the mainstream muslims, the sunnies , deny superiority to any one people, the Shias claim they are the superiors being the direct decendants of the prophet through his daughter Fatima form Ali and Hassan, the two grandsons of the prophet. Allah knows best.<br><b>References : </b><br> Yes.

The division however is just political and cultural, and not religious. There were no such divisions in the time of the prophet. Its only after the time of the prophet, started over the issue, who should rightfully be the leaders over the Muslims.

While the mainstream muslims, the sunnies , deny superiority to any one people, the Shias claim they are the superiors being the direct decendants of the prophet through his daughter Fatima form Ali and Hassan, the two grandsons of the prophet.

Allah knows best.
References :

]]> By: Ruchjat K http://blog.hajjumrahreview.com/performing-umrah/are-the-rituals-performed-for-hajjumrah-the-same-for-both-shias-and-sunnis/comment-page-1#comment-13361 Ruchjat K Sat, 27 Mar 2010 00:39:59 +0000 http://blog.hajjumrahreview.com/performing-umrah/are-the-rituals-performed-for-hajjumrah-the-same-for-both-shias-and-sunnis#comment-13361 Salam. The rituals performed for hajj and umrah are the same based on the hadith of Muhammad pbuh so for both shia's and sunni's and any other islamic sects are the same. The difference between hajj pilgrim and umrah is just only on wuquf in Arafah field and throwing syaitans with small stones in Mina for only hajj pilgrim. Umrah has no wuquf in Arafah and throwing syaitans with stones in Mina Muhammad pbuh followed the way of Ibrahim prophet and his son Ismael prophet when they made it.<br><b>References : </b><br> Salam. The rituals performed for hajj and umrah are the same based on the hadith of Muhammad pbuh so for both shia’s and sunni’s and any other islamic sects are the same.
The difference between hajj pilgrim and umrah is just only on wuquf in Arafah field and throwing syaitans with small stones in Mina for only hajj pilgrim.
Umrah has no wuquf in Arafah and throwing syaitans with stones in Mina
Muhammad pbuh followed the way of Ibrahim prophet and his son Ismael prophet when they made it.
References :

]]> By: ???? ??? ???? http://blog.hajjumrahreview.com/performing-umrah/are-the-rituals-performed-for-hajjumrah-the-same-for-both-shias-and-sunnis/comment-page-1#comment-13360 ???? ??? ???? Sat, 27 Mar 2010 00:02:59 +0000 http://blog.hajjumrahreview.com/performing-umrah/are-the-rituals-performed-for-hajjumrah-the-same-for-both-shias-and-sunnis#comment-13360 Probably not. I have seen different groups of shia pilgrims doing different things during haj and visits.<br><b>References : </b><br> Probably not.

I have seen different groups of shia pilgrims doing different things during haj and visits.
References :

]]>