Is pilgrimage to Saudi Arabia a requirement of Islam?
I’m more Catholic but I’m wondering like isn’t it true that if Muslims were all required to go on Hajj to Saudi Arabia if they can that means that Saudi Arabia kinda can control the religion?
Yes it is required for every Muslim to make journey to the city of Mecca at least once in their life. But how in the world would Saudi Arabia control Islam!? That’s like saying Judaism controls Jerusalem. Jerusalem is were the Jews go on journey. Does Rome Italy control the religion of Catholicism? Use your logic please.
The only was you are dismissed from the Hajj is if you are too poor to afford to get to Mecca.
October 14th, 2009 at 3:54 am
They are - but they can send a proxy if they like.
References :
October 14th, 2009 at 4:03 am
No, it doesn’t mean that Saudi Arabia controls the religion. That’s just where Mecca happens to be.
The hajj is required of a Muslim <only> if the Muslim can afford it. Otherwise, it’s not required.
References :
October 14th, 2009 at 4:46 am
The religious leaders control the religion no one country could ever stop that. To answer your question, it is required if you are able to go. If you have something that is legitimately stopping you than you may not.
References :
October 14th, 2009 at 4:55 am
Yes it is required for every Muslim to make journey to the city of Mecca at least once in their life. But how in the world would Saudi Arabia control Islam!? That’s like saying Judaism controls Jerusalem. Jerusalem is were the Jews go on journey. Does Rome Italy control the religion of Catholicism? Use your logic please.
The only was you are dismissed from the hajj is if you are too poor to afford to get to Mecca.
References :
I’m a Muslim.
October 14th, 2009 at 5:02 am
well they have to do the pilgrimage…..if they can afford it.
Its not soo much saudi arabia as it is mecca.
In terms of saudi arabia controlling islam…no. There is no pope like figure in islam. No central command. There is no clergy at all. There are religious leaders i guess…like imams..sheiks…scholars….but they’re not like a higher class…..every single muslim is also a "priest". If my brother was going to get married…i’d be allowed to conduct the religious aspect of it. I can give sermons…do funerals…lead prayers…etc.
Of course scholars are a little more knowledgeable….you take their advice…but there is nothing that says you have to listen to them.
References :
October 14th, 2009 at 5:40 am
ONLY IF YOU CAN, AS IT REQUIRES MONEY AND HEALTH, IT’S STATED LIKE THAT IN THE HOLY QURAN:
“And Hajj (pilgrimage to Makkah) to the House (Ka‘bah) is a duty that mankind owes to Allaah, those who can afford the expenses (for one’s conveyance, provision and residence); and whoever disbelieves [i.e. denies Hajj (pilgrimage to Makkah), then he is a disbeliever of Allaah], then Allaah stands not in need of any of the ‘Aalameen (mankind, jinn and all that exists)” [Aal Imraan 3:97]
AND IN THE FIVE PILLARS OF ISLAM, CHECK THEM HERE:
http://islamqa.com/en/ref/13569
Ok, we know we don’t create each other and we don’t come to this world from nowhere because when we die we must be going somewhere as well, hence there must be God, if there were many Gods, they would have fought over what to be created and what not to be, probably over who to die and who to live at the same time… so it’s gotta be one God… if that God created us then there must be a reason… could we figure it out on our own? God made it easy and sent us messengers and prophets to show us the way and tell us why… so all the messengers and all the religions are from the same only God, so they’ve got to be complementary to each other, not opposing each other!!! then God must have said His final words in the last message, what is the last message? and how do we know it’s the last one? I guess that would be the religion that believes in all messengers and all books equally… is there such religion? actually yes, Islam does
A True Muslim (man or woman) gets his reward for obeying Allah’s orders (Allah means The God in Arabic) by going to heaven, where he/she are indulged forever in all the good things that were on earth and more, things no one ever dreamt of or heard about. The Holy Quran tells Muslims (men and women) there will be good food, good wine and sex in heaven for all, but not in the bestial way you may think of, but rather in a way that is satisfactory for everyone and better than what was on earth. Heaven is no heartbreak or injustice land.
True Muslims are no terrorists, and Islam never calls for that, Islam means peace, it bans violence unless you were fought so you fight back, it only doesn’t require Muslims to be cowards, and true Muslims understand this very well and never attack civilians.
Islam is the only religion that accepts freedom of religion and asks men to treat women gently like queens.
It’s all in the Holy Quran and the right teachings of prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him).
If some people behave otherwise, then it’s because people behaviour doesn’t necessarily reflect the rulings of their religion always, for example, we can’t (and don’t) judge Christianity by Hitler or Madonna.
And that is another reason why there is heaven and hell after we die, heaven for the obedient and hell for the disobedient and/or oppressor, it’s all going to be decided on the day of resurrection and judgement.
To be a Muslim, you must believe God is only one with no spouses or offspring, believe in his angels (servants not males or females), believe in all his religions, messangers and books equally, the day of judgement, heaven and hell and that everything is in God’s hands and because of his will (good or bad).
Muslims believe God is the only divine who never dies, the creator who deserves to be worshiped, all prophets who came to earth are human messangers sent by him.
Muslims don’t deny christianity, judaism, Jesus or Moses. They believe in them as the noble prophets and messangers of God, love and respect them so much.
We believe the birth of Jesus (messanger of God) was a miracle from God to us, being born by a mother only and with no father. God is the creator, he can do anything.
We believe Jesus (peace be upon him) is NOT dead till today; he wasn’t even murdered or crucified as most people think. God (most glorified) made the man who betrayed Jesus be killed instead by switching their looks for a moment. Jesus was left up to live in heaven until the end of days when he will come back to earth again, with no new teachings or messages but just to make justice prevail instead of oppression, fight the imposter who will claim to be God and (most important) to perform his last prayer with the Muslims announcing he’s too a follower of the last prophet (Muhammad) as all people should… then he really dies like other Prophets and be buried (peace be upon them all). So we’re waiting for you Jesus, Messenger of God, to bring the world peace and pray with us. That’s what prophet Muhammad told us and this is what I believe in, I’m a Muslim
so how do we know it’s true? what is said in the last message and what should we do? read the following, and you’ll figure out for yourself:
References :
http://www.rasoulallah.net/
http://www.islamhouse.com/
http://www.the-right-religion.com/
http://www.qurancomplex.com/default.asp?l=eng
http://www.islam-guide.com/
http://www.islamqa.com/en
http://www.islamreligion.com/articles/204/
http://whyislam.org/Prophethood/ProphetJesus/tabid/82/Default.aspx http://whyislam.org/
October 14th, 2009 at 6:23 am
it is compulsory to go for hajj atleast ones in life time but only if they can afford it.if the person is financially good and can afford going for hajj but he doesnt go then he comites a sin.
References :