Sunnis, the next time you perform pilgrimage, how would you know the person next to you is not a Shia?
How can you let such infidels and disbelievers enter you’re sacred places? I mean, if I was a Sunni, I wouldn’t want to perform Pilgrimage beside no infidel and a disbeliever who curses my mother and loved ones. How can you let such people inside these sacred places? When will you guys stand up and make a protest against Saudi Arabia? When will you boycott Saudi Arabia to get what you want?
Assalamualaikum (Peace be upon you)
Hajj is not only for the Sunnis, nor is it only for the Shias, it is for all those who call themselves Muslims regardless of whatever sectarian affiliation they have, no group has the right to say who should and shouldn’t enter Hajj because by denying any person the right to perform their Hajj, they are effectively declaring Kuffar upon somebody without any conclusive proof and also I should add that Allah alone is the only One who will decide who is Muslim and who isn’t.
Besides Hajj promotes unity between Sunni and Shia Muslims which is a good thing.
And Allah knows best
May Allah provide us with guidance
Salaam
March 6th, 2010 at 4:52 am
Do us a favour and boycott yourselves
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 5:23 am
This has NOTHING to do with Saudi
This has to do with TAQIYAH, the shia say that they are "muslim" when applying for their visas, they dare NOT say that they are shia because they know they will be barred from performing the muslim right of hajj.
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 5:42 am
Kabbah is Not the Property Of Sunni people or ANy other Group .
Understand It and Accept it . live by it ,
My Name is Muhammad Abbas Naqvi . By this half of the World Muslim can easily Understand That I’m From a Shia Family . So, does it Make Any difference no .
In even Wahabies The Father of Famous Mufti Rafi Usmani Mufti Azam Pakistan . Have Wrote in his book that To pray Behind Shia is not Prohibited it’s 100% allowed In Sharia .
Kabbah Is No One’s Property .
If AnyBody do not accept this Truth then proof me Wrong ,
Saudi Arab Can’t Stop Pakistani,Indian , Bangladeshi, Indonesian ir Any other Countries Shias .
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 5:50 am
Good question but protesting against governments is not allowed in Islam
—-
Noub is right, these people are liars. When they ( Shias /Qadianis) apply for visa they say they are " Muslims", they wont reveal their real identity ( that they are filthy Shias or Qadianis)
@ User above
Kabah is OUR ( muslim’s) property, accept it or fook off
@ Sina
Lmaoo " they go their to worship dead people" Lol LOL
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 6:40 am
Shiaa pretend that they are Muslims so we r not allowed to ban them from going to Hajj. imo they go to hajj just to worship the dead people in Al Baqia’
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 7:30 am
Every year, on Ashura, the Shias march down the streets holding signs and never forgetting Imam Hussain AS, and Karbala, and for sure to never accept the Kaffir ibn Kaffir Yazid (L)
Every year the Shias do this, yet i never see Sunnis protesting the same way in making Mecca and Medina strictly for the Muslims, Prophet banned and kicked out all the kaffirs from Mecca, so why are us Shias going in and out without a problem? Why do Saudi let Iranians come into Mecca and perform Hajj?
for all the idiots, that say Shia say Muslim on visa
1) they let many Iranians inside (95% of Iranians are Shia)
2) If ur little yazidi brain hasnt noticed, Shia identify themselves as Muslims first, than Shias internally
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 8:10 am
Assalamualaikum (Peace be upon you)
Hajj is not only for the Sunnis, nor is it only for the Shias, it is for all those who call themselves Muslims regardless of whatever sectarian affiliation they have, no group has the right to say who should and shouldn’t enter Hajj because by denying any person the right to perform their Hajj, they are effectively declaring Kuffar upon somebody without any conclusive proof and also I should add that Allah alone is the only One who will decide who is Muslim and who isn’t.
Besides Hajj promotes unity between Sunni and Shia Muslims which is a good thing.
And Allah knows best
May Allah provide us with guidance
Salaam
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 8:44 am
I really dislike getting involved in these Shia/Sunni conflicts, it brings my iman to a low point. One thing I have to say to you, please don’t be so assumptive. It is very dangerous to slander a person. Personally - I have never heard any Shia (in real life) say anything bad about Aisha (ra) Though, if anyone does curse her, that is totally wrong. Allah (swt) knows best and He is the only judge.
Peace.
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 8:59 am
listen , last thing i will care about is judging ppl.
as long as u are far from me, as long as u don’t insult me, nor u insult what i believe in , in my face so i don’t give a shyt what u follow. u have a freedom to follow whatever u want. u say the shahada and i say the shahada so this place is for both of us…. what comes after that, well that’s for Allah to judge not me. i cant even help myself so how can i judge anyone else.and whoever stop u should fear Allah,
if Allah gave me the chance to go and do hajj ( Ya Rabb) , last thing i will care about is sects.
and personally, who am i to know whats in the hearts of the ppl, let Allah judge.
salam
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 9:17 am
All Muslims are equal. Muslims do not consider political differences as Religious differences.
Prophet Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses Jesus, and Muhammad were Muslims.
Hazrat Abu Bakr, Umar, Usman, and Ali were Muslims.
They were not Sunni, or Shia. We are also Muslims, PERIOD.
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 9:58 am
Who granted the key of the Kabaa to Sunnis? This is news to me.
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 10:15 am
Well sometimes the Saudi authorities apprehend the shia apostates trying to enter our holy site, and so they should. The Saudi system (rightly) teaches that the Shia are NOT Muslims, and they will launch a crack down on them soon hopefully.
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 10:29 am
Wait shias aren’t muslim so what are they doing in Mecca?
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 11:15 am
It does not belong to just Sunni’s, it is for all MUSLIMS.
I love how all Muslims are gathered, it is the one place that brings us all together as one Ummah, where you completely forget your difference. When you are there, you don’t give a second thought of what sect a person might be around you, you’re so focused on you and Allah. ?
They’re not doing any harm are they? The more we complain or prototest as you suggested, the bigger the devision between us Muslims.
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 11:49 am
You can tell by the indent in their forhead from the stone shirk they pray on.
I ask are you shia, they say yes and I slap them and say well get the hell away from me then!
Then I take my stone pebbles I was going to throw at the shytan, and start launching them in his direction repeatedly.
I wil not get in a cab if they are shia, I say are you shia, they say yes I say move your donkey along then boy! Then I slap a bumper sticker on the donkey as he goes by that says "Ali Ra. gave his daughter to a murderer? How so?"
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 12:31 pm
Exactly, this what is expected from sunni cult.
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 1:07 pm
u r not muslim so its not ur headache to think of this issue. if strict people like Wahhabi’s (saudis) don’t have any problems then why u r shouting?
my advice to u : just go to sleep and chill.
References :
March 6th, 2010 at 1:26 pm
Why should it make a difference if hes shia or not?
References :
May 12th, 2010 at 8:03 am
Salaams, one and all.
I’m not really surprised by the strong views and arguments of some of my Sunni brothers and sisters.
The fact is that most of the hate and vitriol being spouted is nothing new, it’s seeds have been laid even from the time of the Prophet (PBUH)and continue to this very day I(as evidenced through some of the comments on here).
Ignorance is never an excuse for such attacks and nor is it acceptable to simply follow ones forefathers and what has been handed down. Firm logical reasoning, supported by the Noble Quran and authentic Hadith can enlighten one immensely. I urge all those that have some seriously preconceived ideas to establish the truth for themselves.
For all those who view Shia as polytheists, infidels and whatever else one wants to call us, I would refer you to Shabhey Peshawar (Peshawar Nights). The content of which is a serious and informative discussion relating to some of the reservations some of my fellow Muslims have concerning the existence and practices of Shia between Sunni and Shia Ulema.
Go forth and seek knowledge, it’s all contained within your own books. Please have a read and I’ll be happy to discuss your thoughts/views on this subject and love to see what people make of the discussions and what conclusions they arrive at.
I thank you for your time and pray that we all find the way to the truth.
July 7th, 2010 at 6:41 am
nobody can claim to be perfect or mainstream muslims. embrace humanity before embracing islam. be polite with the words u use. the prophet (sa)taught us the same.accept what is common between shias & sunnis and avoid pointing differences between the both. it is bcoz of our ignorance that we the muslims are so backward.its not too late
July 7th, 2010 at 6:59 am
Allah would definitely not like those group of people who believe in Allah and hate those who believe in Allah.
be a true believer